Electoral Outcomes: Heads Or Tails, The Courts Still Win


By SHEDDY OZOENE

In recent years, the courts have become increasingly involved in determining the outcomes of political contests in Nigeria. They have become a major part of the troubles voters face in the country’s electoral process.

A politician who can compromise INEC officials can manipulate election results and walk away with victory. When challenged, he simply tells his opponents to go to court. Nigerians know what that means. In many cases, it is an expensive and frustrating journey that leads nowhere.

But there is another side to it. A politician who loses at the polling units but has the right connections and resources can also turn to the courts to reclaim victory. We have seen this happen repeatedly. The result is that Nigerians are increasingly losing faith in a system where their votes do not always determine who governs them.

It was against this background that the Chairman of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), Professor Joash Amupitan, made a declaration worth reflecting on at the 56th Annual National Conference of the Nigerian Association of Law Teachers (NALT), held at the University of Abuja. He said Nigeria could no longer afford a situation in which courts determine the outcome of elections. His position was simple: electoral victories should be decided by the votes cast by Nigerians, not by the legal battles that follow elections.

Appointed in October 2025, Amupitan appears genuinely concerned about this trend. As the country approaches the 2027 general elections, his statement brings back memories of how our electoral process has steadily lost the confidence of many Nigerians. Going out to vote has, in many instances, become an exercise in frustration. The votes either do not count because INEC fails the people or because the courts eventually overturn their choices. As Professor Chidi Odinkalu once observed, the courts have turned themselves into the ‘selectorate’.

READ ALSO  The Rotten Apples At Louis Edet House

Amupitan’s position is commendable. But recent developments suggest that his declaration may remain little more than an academic statement. Ironically, the courts seem to have taken notice of his remarks and decided to act on them. Only that, instead of waiting until after elections to determine who wins, they now appear to be shaping the political contest before voters have had their say.

In other words, they seem determined to win, heads or tails.

Why do I say so?

Judicial decisions in recent months, particularly as the countdown to the 2027 elections gathers pace, have been disturbing. The manner in which opposition parties and their candidates have been caught up in court battles raises serious questions.

If this trend continues, President Bola Ahmed Tinubu of the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC) could find himself facing a badly weakened opposition, if not emerging as the only major contender in the presidential race.

In recent times, Nyesom Wike has become a familiar name whenever politically sensitive court cases are discussed. His public comments have often been followed by judicial outcomes that appear to confirm his predictions. How he acquired, or came to be perceived as having, such influence over judicial outcomes is a matter of public speculation. What cannot easily be ignored, however, is the frequency with which his predictions have appeared to come true, particularly in cases involving the APC and its political ally in the so-called Rainbow Coalition, the PDP.

One striking example is the November 5, 2026, Federal High Court judgment which effectively dismantled the leadership of the African Democratic Congress (ADC) led by David Mark.

READ ALSO  Tinubu, Peter Obi And The South-East’s Dilemma

Wike had, on previous occasions, boasted that Atiku Abubakar, the ADC’s presidential candidate, was not properly nominated and would not be on the ballot in 2027. In his judgment, Justice Peter Lifu of the Federal High Court, Abuja, declared the Mark-led executive committee illegal and invalidated decisions taken by it, including its role in the nomination of Atiku as the ADC’s presidential candidate.

The judgment has generated considerable controversy. The ADC sees it as an attempt by the ruling APC to cripple the opposition and deny Nigerians a credible alternative in 2027.

INEC Chairman, Professor Amupitan, has also come under criticism for declaring that the commission would obey Justice Lifu’s judgment despite an earlier judgment by another Federal High Court judge, Justice Musa Liman, on July 2, 2026, which upheld the emergence of the David Mark-led ADC leadership.

Both judges sit in the same Federal High Court. Neither is superior to the other. This raises an obvious question: how does INEC intend to reconcile the two judgments, and why does it appear to have chosen to give effect to one rather than the other?

It may be premature to conclude that Wike’s prediction has come to pass. But if Justice Lifu’s judgment survives the legal challenges against it, the consequences for the 2027 presidential contest could be enormous.

Atiku Abubakar remains a major opposition figure, particularly in the North, where he has been working to mobilise support against Tinubu’s re-election bid. The slogan, “Ba m’ayi” (we are not doing again), is increasingly being heard across the region, reflecting growing resistance to another Tinubu presidency.

Tinubu’s political standing in the South, particularly outside the South-West, is also a subject of considerable debate. Against this background, the judicial intervention in the affairs of the ADC raises troubling questions. Atiku, who appears well-positioned to benefit from the growing anti-Tinubu sentiment in the North, now faces a serious political setback.

READ ALSO  Who Does YIAGA AFRICA Really Work For?

I do not subscribe to the argument that courts should have no role in resolving political party disputes, whether before or after elections. Courts exist to settle genuine disputes and protect the rights of parties. But there is a difference between dispensing justice and becoming instruments in the political struggle for power.

Unfortunately, the growing perception is that judicial interventions are being used to weaken opponents of the Federal Government and dismantle opposition party structures, with obvious political benefits for the President and his party. That perception is dangerous, whether or not it reflects the actual intentions of the courts.

This brings us back to Amupitan’s declaration. How can INEC guarantee that the votes will count when the political contest itself is increasingly being shaped by judicial decisions before election day? How can Nigerians have confidence in the process when the fate of political parties and their candidates appears to depend more on courtrooms than on the choices of voters?

As things stand, the INEC Chairman’s declaration appears dead on arrival.

The courts have turned Nigerian politics into a game of heads or tails. A politician may win at the polling units and lose in court. Another may lose the internal battle for his party’s leadership but find judicial decisions determining whether he can even contest an election.

Either way, the courts win. The voters lose.

And that is certainly not the will of the people Professor Amupitan says he wants to protect.


By People&Politics

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts